Assessing Collaborative Efforts
In this module, you watched two video programs in which George Siemens discussed strategies for assessing collaborative learning communities in the online environment, and for creating and maintaining successful online learning communities. Both instructors and learners must take responsibility for achieving this goal. Occasionally, you may run across a student who does not like to work in groups or collaborate with peers. He or she may even request to work on a project alone rather than in a cooperative group.
As an instructor, there are several issues to consider:
- How should participation in a collaborative learning community be assessed? How do the varying levels of skill and knowledge students bring to a course affect the instructor's "fair and equitable assessment" of learning?
- If a student does not want to network or collaborate in a learning community for an online course, what should the other members of the learning community do? What role should the instructor play? What impact would this have on his or her assessment plan?
Reflect on these questions in your blog. Reference your readings and video programs from this module, along with another blog post dealing with the topic of assessing collaborative learning. Be sure to link to all of the resources you cite in your blog.
Siemens discusses the challenges that educators face in the fact that there is a struggles with how to assess students because there is a shift in the way that educators teach. We are going from individual learning experiences to collaboration between colleagues. How do we assess a group assignment? There are four ways that Siemens introduced for assessment in a collaborative environment. Peers can assess one another in a collaborative group by using a rating scale. Another way to assess is that students can receive feedback from the online community on their assignment that they have worked on. After obtaining the feedback, they can make corrections to the project. Not all assessments have to have a mark. Another assessment is that educators assess based on contributions such as using a wiki. Lastly, educators assess based on metrics from learning management systems.
What happens when there is someone that will not participate in the online community? Siemens discusses that there are some students that struggle with working in a collaborative environment. The best way to get these students to participate is to change the assessment. The instructor should play a big role by showing students how to effectively participate and be successful. Have a practical experience.
References:
Laureate Education, Inc. (2008).Learning communities. Baltimore: Author.
Laureate Education, Inc. (2008). Assessment of collaboration. Baltimore: Author.
Kasey,
ReplyDeleteHi,
Great post! Very thoughtful!
In many ways, I agree with Siemen regarding peer reviews; however, there may be times that peers don't jive with one another and the assessment ends up negatively biased. It seems fair practice would be to utilize multiple assessment strategies in order to obtain a comprehensive overview of individual students' work.
Moreover, because our world really requires that we learn how to work together it is important, in my view, that students that are uncomfortable with group interactions (a student with Asperger’s syndrome comes to mind)could be eased into the group work. Consequently, this could be a teachable moment for all involved.
Cheers,
Cynthia
Feedback from other students is very important. This allows the students to take part in the learning and assessment process also. You listed some good ways to assess the students' learning.
ReplyDeleteI think that many students are afraid of the response that they will get from their own response. Once the students see how important their input is and how supportive their classmates really are, they will feel more comfortable and ready to collaborate and work with each other in many other projects or assignments.
ReplyDeleteThe instructor is the ultimate driving force in online collaboration. There should be clear expectations on how assessment will take place. I believe that if a student does not want to participate there is good reason and it is the instructors responsibility to find out why ensuring that the student will have the opportunity to achieve success in the on line learning community.The possibility of the student working alone to complete a project might be a good idea but how would the student receive feedback from peers?
ReplyDeleteThis is very good and informative post for the students for online education program.
ReplyDeleteThank's for this post.
Online education in India